Photo by Steve Fernie

Sad demise of the paper coffee cup

Share This

The bean counters at the World Wildlife Fund found that it takes more than 200 litres of water just to produce one cup of latte coffee (see flash presentation below).

Water wastage is only one aspect of the total environmental impact. Another alarming facet is the amount of solid waste produced by the ubiquitous throwaway paper cup — the most unnecessary environmental side effect of the coffee craving.

This is known, by the environmentally astute, as the “paper cup problem”.

Paper cup problem

Everyday many of us decide to take our coffee away in a paper cup. It is easy to imagine the environmental consequence of this decision — billions of cups, millions of trees and tons of greenhouse gases (estimates vary) every year.

The word “paper” might suggest that the paper cup is easily recycled and that it is not as bad as its plastic cousin. However, most paper cups are coated with a plastic resin (i.e., polyethylene) for durability and convenience, therefore making both their composting and recycling uncommon and raising the specter of carcinogenic chemical leeching.

According to one study on the environmental impacts of paper cups, each cup, taking into account the paper, the paper sleeve, production and shipping, emits about 0.11 kilograms of CO2.

Depending on forestry practices (and whether they are sustainable or not) paper cup production results in loss of trees, ecosystem degradation and a reduction in the planet’s carbon absorption capacity.

In our world of shrinking forests and growing landfill, continued use of the paper cup is both redundant and unsustainable.

Changing the way we think about coffee

Every aspect of the coffee industry has been a prominent target of environmental and social justice campaigners who seek to inform people about the impacts that their daily habits have on other parts of the world.

Awareness campaigns encouraging people to drink fair-trade coffee have reached mainstream usage, even in some instances through the most vilified of coffee chains.

Interestingly, bioplastics, derived from corn, sugar cane and other renewable biomass resources, are emerging as a clever way to reduce our coffee footprints.

Corn-based plastic (polylactic acid — PLA) coffee mugs in particular have been gaining popularity with drinkers. One example we know about is Micup (let us know about others).

They can help reduce coffee-related waste, reduce dependence on carbon-based inputs, such as oil, and can be disposed of in closed loop recycling programs — that is, programs that convert waste to make other products.

Admittedly there is a small carbon footprint from reusable bioplastic mugs through their production and also from rinsing in hot water. Furthermore, unsolved problems, including the fact that recycling plants may not yet be equipped to handle PLA, are contributing to consumer confusion.

Nonetheless, one reusable mug is obviously a better option than dozens if not hundreds of disposable cups.

Usable re-usables

Drinking your coffee in the shop is the best thing you can do … the coffee just seems to taste better!

Realistically, significant reduction in the impacts of paper cup consumption requires solutions that fit the current lifestyles and habits of coffee drinkers.

Reusable and recyclable cups are the future for all on-the-go coffee aficionados. It’s certainly an issue people want to talk about, as the 1200 + blogs about paper cups and the lack of convenient alternatives can attest.

One problem with alternatives, such as flasks and thermoses, is that many mugs do not fit under the spout of different coffee machines used in retail outlets and cafés. But surely that can’t be too difficult to find a work around for.

Additionally, in order to maintain market share, some retail outlets make it harder than it needs to be for customers to use other brands of bring-your-own coffee mugs. But as demand increases the clever coffee makers will soon realize that they have to change.

Attempts by retailers to enforce brand loyalty can stifle people’s desire to bring their own cup and have prevented larger scale environmental mitigation from taking effect to date.

The time is ripe for patrons to shun the paper version and insist instead on wielding a smart and reusable vessel. This way coffee drinkers can lead change themselves, rather than waiting for it to happen.

So what are you waiting for?

  • marcus

    Well done! This really makes you think about the magnification of the actions of each individual and the savings that could be made by small changes from each of us. Perhaps it should be renamed “The Happy Demise of the Paper Coffee Cup”. Very interesting stuff.

  • Andrew Warner

    Nice article, I’m slightly skeptical about whether people will actually have the discipline to use a reusable cup on an everyday basis. Having said that I think it’s great that there are people out there looking for alternatives to the little things we do in our lives that generate waste on a global scale which many of us aren’t aware of.

  • sondra lavine

    i love ourworld 2, but this post surprised me a bit.. just sticks out as being not so well written; nearly every paragraph is a sentence, the multitude of links offsite are tedious, requiring the reader to spend a lot more time digging around other posts to get -the facts-. i’m looking forward to more of your substantial posts!!

  • Dee

    Hi thanks for the varying perspectives on this issue. It seems like everything we do we have some kind of impact on the environment. Does it come to each individual to decide on what that impact is? The consumer confusion article counters any environmental benefit of reusable mugs. How do we know we make more or less of an impact?

  • http://agilog.blogspot.com/ agilog

    thanks for this article. try to be so green, but walk around with these fancy to go cups, silly. 5 to go cups a week, that’s a lot of garbage.

  • Ranui

    I’m having cup right now! It doesn’t taste as good.

  • Dels

    With regard to Dee’s comment, I have my doubts about that consumer confusion article. The world has never been short of food or food supplies, it’s only ever been imbalanced in the way food is distributed to the worlds population – you only need to go to the U.S. to see that. I think with the one certainty that oil is going to be in shortage, this means that the less oil based containers (for example) that we use the better…the consumer confusion article sounds more like 1 bit of an arguement against alternative materials (and a questionable arguement at that) when there’s a plethora in favour of them

  • Amy

    Consumer confusion is not necessarily a bad thing I think, since it means people are (finally!) at least thinking/talking about the issues! Apathy and inaction are far worse, don’t you think? So, as to Dee’s question about how we know we’re having more or less impact, I think Dels is on the right track about traditional plastic (included coated take-out coffee cups + lids!) and the waste it engenders being a HUGE problem and PLA being one alternative, that while maybe ideal, is still the lesser of two evils. If you really want to make no impact, don’t take-out at all or only rarely and then defintely with your own cup, be it PLA or stainless (I’ve had my stainless travel mug for 10 years so it’s footprint has totally been erased by now!). Good riddance to paper cups!

  • Ely

    Very interesting! It takes something like this to remind us all what a huge impact every little practice can have on the environment. I like the idea of a standard flask that could be used in many different coffee shops. If it were publicised, I think many people would go for it! Good work and thanks!

  • Mary

    gee…I wonder if the people behind Micup wrote this article??? what’s the bet they did? I love the environment and am making sacrifices – to have no car, fly less, eat for the planet – but the constant hijacking of the green agenda for profit is making me sick

  • Amy

    I remembered reading a sustainability comparison on this topic and thought I could share: http://www.triplepundit.com/pages/askpablo-mugs.php

  • Lin Let

    Let’s think about how we CAN actually work around the fact that many cafes refuse to let consumers use their own mugs / thermos cups to takeaway their coffee.
    * Petition the cafe owner or company CEO & board?
    * Fill out copious numbers of customer feedback forms?
    * Throw a tantrum in the shop if they don’t let you use your own mug?
    It seems to me that this step of the process also warrants our effort. Additional suggestions needed!

  • the e-squire

    I think Mary’s comment about “hijacking of the green agenda” alerts us to a most important faultline underlining the search for environmentally sustainable solutions.

    For decades, dedicated defenders of the earth, ahead of their time, have fought bravely from the fringes. However, their lack of critical resources (i.e. money) has limited their ability to generate substantial change in people’s behaviour, in particular for issues that have distant impacts upon people’s lives, such as their consumption of paper or plastic.

    In an ideal world, we should realise community and government driven solutions that put the planet before profit. But the world is not an ideal place. So should we reject creative enterprise from those motivated by profit? Or can we take advantage of them, as they take advantage of us, for good environmental outcomes? What choice do we have?

  • Graham

    I agree with Lin – any change like this has to also be accompanied by some broader form of social movement, probably from the so-called ‘early adopters’ in order for it to really take off. I think petitioning some of the larger chains is a great idea. I think the difficulty especially with individual cafes is that they are often tied into exclusive deals with cup manufacturers which is why they refuse ppl who come with their own mugs, which might be a tricky issue to get around.

  • George S.

    An ingenius idea!!

  • betty

    The altruistic NGO vs. for-profit company debate is interesting, and one that has never really been addressed (hopefully a potential OurWorld article in the future?)

    I too, like Amy, am wondering how to grapple with the issue of companies ‘hijacking’ the green agenda. We want companies to be sustainable and think about their climate footprint, so do we support them when they do go ‘green’ but still make money, or can only green products be produced by organizations who make no profit?

    Assuming if you believe the latter, then does that mean we shouldn’t support companies like the Body Shop, or People Tree, etc. Conversely, does that mean NGOs like Oxfam shouldn’t have stores because despite selling sustainable products, they still make profits from it..

    Personally, having worked for (and started) an NGO, it’s incredibly hard to do anything without funds. Lack of funds is one of the biggest issue why many new NGOs today fail to ‘compete’ with companies. We couldn’t pay to keep talented and ethically-minded volunteers (we all have our lives to live and bills to pay) and any meagre funds we did receive were from governments who placed many constraints on how we could spend it (e.g. avoid topics that would make the government look bad!)

    So is combining altruism with commercialisation a possible way out of this quagmire..?

    Over to you OurWorld.

  • Tym

    Thanks Mark and Raj for writing another outstanding article. I have forwarded the site onto many others who are very interested in what Our World is saying.

    I first read this article thinking the number was amazing, but a little over the top. How is it even possible that my cup full of milk and coffee uses 200 litres of water to make? I found an interesting site called GreenBiz.com ( http://www.greenbiz.com/blog/2009/02/26/the-anatomy-a-latte) that had the breakdown as well as some further information about the paper cup problem. The author, Mark Gunther, states that “[t]he water to grow coffee, after all, comes in the form of tropical rainstorms, which are abundant.” Does this explain why it takes 143 of the 200 litres (that being over 70% of the total) to grow coffee where water is not essentially wasted, but there already? Isn’t 200 litres therefore a little deceptive?

    However, this article is not about the issue that all these lattes that we consume are using up our fresh water supply, but that there is a limit on how much is out there and we should take steps to ensure that we make informed decisions when consuming products.

    Having said that, I am currently drinking a Starbucks Venti Latte (in a disposable cup) and it is still delicious.

  • Tatiana

    This is fantastic article! Wow, I honestly never thought about the impact of paper cups! I did notice, however, that when I get tea, i get given TWO cups because the water is very hot! i feel soooo bad now
    :(
    I think the ‘Micup’ will be a fantastic solution though. Do you know the amount of times I want to take my own coffee/tea to university, but i CANT because my thermos is too big or has a weird shape (i end up burning my tongue trying to drink it on the train or car without spilling it!) Not only is it reusable, but its the perfect shape!! Although it will be hard to convince everyone to take their own mugs to work/university initially, I think (like any fad) it’ll kick in once everyone is holding their own personalised ‘micup’! Something to look out for, for sure :)

  • Shane

    The paper cup problem certainly is concerning. Its an addiction most of us share and the large companies arent doing enough to address it. Its a case where technology needs to catch up with a COST effective solution.

    The comments (above) about ‘for profit’ or ‘hijacking agendas’ in this industry are ridiculous. EVERYTHING that happens quickly in this world needs incentive from all parties, its the foundation of our progress and innovation. TO suggest that environmental problems be fixed without commercial solutions without an alternative approach / solution / reason to make it happen is not productive. i own a cafe and i know this all too well!

    Consumers use disposable cups for convenience, and much of the science behind the lack of a solution has been limited because most of the solutions are looking at trying to fix the paper cup (make it biodegradable etc). This is fantastic and i hope it gets there one day, but solutions need to be looked at from a production perspective as well. There is no point fixing the paper cup to be biodegradable if we have to chop down 6 million tree’s a year to keep making them.

  • Nav

    Great article guys! I had no idea how close we were to some real break throughs in reusable materials until I read this article. Can we really afford to be elitist about who brings us practical alternatives to such pressing problems? Everyone agrees that paper cups generate a bunch of waste. Paper cups are (currently) cheap to produce. What incentive do most companies have to move away from this harmful industry? I applaud anyone who comes up with something that can shift the cost/benefit equation into the green.

  • Amyn

    great article!

  • http://www.enviromantics.com/ bariana

    Another issue in making reusable cups an everyday reality is dealing with washing up. Maybe other people don’t mind, but I don’t want to carry around or hand over a dirty cup. Even small drips of coffee in my bag are bad news and it’s just not quite right washing up your cup in public toilets. I rarely buy take away hot drinks anyway, so currently I’m just sticking to drinking-in as my way of avoiding the waste issue.

  • http://ourworld.unu.edu/en/2009/06/09/%e2%80%9cplenty-of-fish-in-the-sea%e2%80%9d/ “Plenty of fish in the sea” | OurWorld 2.0

    [...] industry, especially since the Unilever corporation is one of its founders. As we have seen via comments on previous Our World 2.0 stories, concerned citizens are grappling with the role that corporations should play [...]

  • http://ourworld.unu.edu/jp/2009/06/09/%e6%b5%b7%e3%81%8c%e3%82%82%e3%81%9f%e3%82%89%e3%81%99%e9%a3%9f%e3%81%a8%e3%83%a9%e3%82%a4%e3%83%95%e3%82%b9%e3%82%bf%e3%82%a4%e3%83%ab%e3%82%92%e5%ae%88%e3%82%8b 海がもたらす食とライフスタイルを守る! | Ourworld 2.0 beta

    [...] ユニリーバが創設者の1社であることから、MSCは食糧産業に密接に関連しているとして非難を浴びている。これまでOurWorld2.0の記事に寄せられたコメントを通じて見てきた通り、自らがしばしば引き起こしていると非難されている環境問題の解決に向けて、企業は担うべき役割を負うべきだと考えている人々がいる。 [...]

  • http://ourworld.unu.edu/jp/2009/06/09/%e6%b5%b7%e3%81%8c%e3%82%82%e3%81%9f%e3%82%89%e3%81%99%e9%a3%9f%e3%81%a8%e3%83%a9%e3%82%a4%e3%83%95%e3%82%b9%e3%82%bf%e3%82%a4%e3%83%ab%e3%82%92%e5%ae%88%e3%82%8b 海がもたらす食とライフスタイルを守る! | Ourworld 2.0 beta

    [...] ユニリーバが創設者の1社であることから、MSCは食糧産業に密接に関連しているとして非難を浴びている。これまでOurWorld2.0の記事に寄せられたコメントにも見られるように、環境問題の解決に向けて、その元凶としばしば非難される企業自身が自己責任として担うべき役割を負うべきと考える人々がいる。 [...]

  • http://greentrashcan.com/greenblog/2009/05/19/changing-the-way-we-think-about-coffee/ Changing the way we think about Coffee. « – The Green Trash Can Blog

    [...] Sad demise of the paper coffee cup [...]

  • Nina

    Why do people need paper cups, anyway? Because everyone is always running and needs to grab the coffee “to go.” Even if they are sitting “in” and drinking their coffee, they still have a “gotta run” mentally and use paper cups. I think people need to learn to “slow down and smell the coffee.” That is, ask for a ceramic cup, sit down and savor the flavor…even if it’s only for fifteen minutes. It’s better for the environment and better for our sanity…our taste buds will smile too!

  • http://prettygreenliving.com/?p=40 Pretty Green Living » Throwaway Cup Alternatives

    [...] One of the most succinct sources I perused was One World 2.0’s discussion titled the Sad Demise of the Paper Coffee Cup.  As a heads-up, the stats on water usage and carbon footprints are [...]

  • eventsupplies2

    I think there is slightly more to the situation, you would need to reuse a ceramic cup a huge amount of times just to break even with the energy used to produce a simple paper cup. In many ways it is a case of swings and roundabouts..

    Robert Daniel

  • http://best-coffeemaker-reviews.com/cuisinart-dcc-1000.html Best Coffee Maker Reviews

    Being a coffee lover that I am, I hate to see how it is destroying our environment. I think the best solution to this is to brew our own coffee at our own homes instead of buying from starbucks, peet's, etc. That way we could reduce the water wastage and paper being thrown away.

  • Emile

    Paper cups are not about to go away. As concerned as I am about the eco aspects of our habits, I have to admit that paper and styro do not have viable alternatives yet, all things considered. The problem with paper cups is not so much what it takes to produce (overall it is still the most eco-friendly alternative to all else, we just have to read a bit more widely to realize that), but the relative inability of the recycling industry to deal with two challenges – 1/ coupling of the paper cup with plastic lid, which makes separation at the material recovery facilities difficult and ineffective; and b/the relatively small volume of recyclable material the paper cups represent in the grand schema of things, is a deterrent for the paper recovery industry to invest in machinery for stripping the poly coating from cups so that clean prime fibre can be recovered and reused. I believe the solution is in coming up with technological inventions to resolve these.

  • Payton

    This article is nice, but the presentation was complete nonsense. It takes nowhere near 50gallons to produce one cup of latte including all that goes into producing the paper cup it goes into. I find it interesting they failed to reveal where they got their data from, they merely pray on peoples gullibility and willingness to believe anything they hear or read simply because someone says it’s true.

  • Anonymous

    It looks like the Republican party, now in control, has brought back one-use cups to the US Congress cafe.

    http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/feb/28/republicans-foam-coffee-cup-environmentally-bad

  • Nanandjames

    Hello,
    One thing I haven’t read is that even if you bring your own mug, the coffee place uses a paper cup anyway to measure the size of your drink!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=5203965 David Mullin

    And after the people at the paper plants, factories, and farms lose their jobs from the decreased demand, the government won’t have any tax dollars to invest in renewable resources.   This article also assumes people never throw out their reusable cups, but they do and often because they don’t last, people lose them, or ruin them in the dishwasher.  How much water does it take (or is polluted) to make steel cups, plastic cups, the rubber around the lid, the plastic lid, etc.?  We need a solution but outside of everybody putting their mouths right up to the faucet, this video is nonsense.