The Gamo Highlands are perched high above the African Rift Valley in Southwestern Ethiopia. This isolated area is one of the most densely populated parts of rural Africa that have been farmed sustainably since agriculture was created 10,000 years ago. The zone is currently home to four million people whose culture and ecology have remained intact in the face of both colonialism and globalization.
However, as the short film A Thousand Suns (embedded below) illustrates, the worldview of the Gamo people that enabled this — and that could be fundamental in maintaining long-term sustainability, both in the region and beyond — is under unprecedented external threat.
The Gamo system
The Gamo region is basically devoid of roads, yet it is unique in its resistance to the food shortages and famines that have devastated much of the country. This is due to a unique traditional food system that interweaves a diverse number of tree, root, cereal, and vegetable crops with forestry and livestock production.
The defining aspect of land-use in the Gamo highlands is a set of intricate and well-enforced traditional laws called wagas. These laws stem from the belief that everything is connected and bound in a delicate balance. Together wagas form a natural resource management system that dictates everything from interpersonal relationships to the conservation and preservation of pasture, forest, soil, and water. Because all of the wagas are interconnected, if any one aspect is denied or imbalanced then the whole system is understood to be at risk. Gamoan elder Abera Ogato explains:
“Here we know that sacred forests protect waters. The pastureland is for the livestock. The livestock make the manure to fertilize the crops. Without manure there is not enough fertilizer for the highland soil. So to maintain productivity from a plot of land you must have all these things in balance.”
Diversity in many ways defines the agro-ecosystem of the Gamo Highlands. It has a varied physical landscape, the communities are geographically isolated and the agricultural system incorporates an enormous genetic diversity of crop species. Due to the subsistence nature of farming and the availability of locally-adapted crops, individual farmers maintain an extremely high diversity of seeds and can name literally hundreds of crop varieties ranging from enset, barley and taro to yams, wheat and oromo potato.
Threats to the Gamo
The Gamo is a unique system in which people and nature have co-existed sustainably for millennia. But in the last few years, the evangelical Protestant Church has made inroads into the most remote areas and is eroding the traditional animist social structures that have until now bound the people of the Gamo to each other and the environment.
Members of these outside-funded parishes and schools have disdain for traditional values and have even begun to act in ways that run counter to Gamo culture, including cutting down sacred trees, disrupting community meetings, planting crops in pasture land, and denouncing indigenous leaders as backward or even evil. The results have been destructive, even to the point of causing violence between communities.
Shot in Ethiopia, New York and Kenya, A Thousand Suns explores the modern world’s unjustifiable sense of separation from and superiority over nature, and how this is being imposed upon the people of Gamo. Six months after filming was completed, the Ethiopian government — at the behest of evangelical Protestant missionaries in the region — took away the organizational rights of 42 indigenous groups who focus on preserving the traditional cultures of the Gamo.
“I think the challenge, as we look at various religious systems and cosmologies, is to identify what is helpful to our current situation… indigenous peoples had a sense of limits and of taking only what was needed from the earth and knowing what the earth needed to replenish itself.”
— Mary Evelyn Tucker, Author, Professor at Yale Divinity School
There is another threat looming on the horizon for the people of the Gamo. In 2006, two of the United States’ biggest foundations, The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and the Rockefeller Foundation, joined forces to end hunger in Africa. Their Nairobi-based initiative is called the Alliance for a Green Revolution in Africa (AGRA) and its US $262 million budget aims to bring a ‘new’ Green Revolution to Africa.
According to Samuel Muhunyu of Slow Food Kenya & Network for Eco-farming in Africa and Gathuru Mburu of the Institute for Culture and Ecology, AGRA intends to move farming away from household food security and into an external market-based agriculture model. Muhunya makes his own views very clear on how best to ensure food security:
“Putting the entire seed sector in the hands of companies, local or foreign, eventually means the same thing. It’s corporate. While actually it is the farmers that have the skills. The farmers have the traditional knowledge. We need to develop structures for more village-based seed banks for communities… That’s the most sustainable approach to food security.”
Through loans, farmers are encouraged by AGRA to use external inputs, such as expensive genetically modified seeds, chemical pesticides and fertilizers. As long as crops succeed then all is well, but when they fail the farmer is at risk of losing everything because they are now at the mercy of an external market system that dictates whether or not they receive an income.
Many opponents of AGRA say that it is essentially a mechanism to generate profits for multi-national corporations. They point to the fact that the companies behind AGRA include Monsanto, Syngenta and Dupont — all of which are involved not only in the production of chemical inputs, but in the patenting of the genetically modified seeds that are being promoted by AGRA. These companies therefore stand to profit from the expansion of AGRA in Africa.
“Africa does not need another religion…It needs supportive, investive and ultimately farmer-focused interventions that will allow African farmers to further evolve and develop their own farming systems.”
– Achim Steiner, UNEP Executive Director
While former UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan, as the Chair of AGRA, supports this model of development, a 2008 report from the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) — entitled Organic Agriculture and Food Security in Africa — argues that farming that does not use chemical pesticides and fertilizers is the best way to ensure food security in Africa.
Current Executive Director of UNEP, Dr. Achim Steiner, explains:
“Organic agriculture is sometimes portrayed as an exclusive philosophy and science. But certainly eco-agriculture, I think, is a more appropriate entry point for farmers and farming policies in Africa to evolve. Africa does not need another religion, another philosophy to arrive on the continent. It needs a series of supportive, investive and ultimately farmer-focused interventions that will allow African farmers to further evolve and develop their own farming systems.”
Global significance of the Gamo
Globally, we continue to grapple with the question of how a growing human population can co-exist with the natural environment. The Gamo’s unique agricultural system and the worldview that sustains it provide valuable clues as to how this might be possible in the future.
“In many ways, the coming in of all this Green Revolution technology parallels the sort of coming in of these evangelical Christian voices to the Gamo, in that [it is] taking the landscape in which you live and making it something that is external to you.”
— Leah Samburg, Ecologist, Gamo Biodiversity Expert
The people of the Gamo have developed the ability to conserve crop genetic resources while practising highly productive farming strategies. Globally, we are down to two or three viable strains of our most important food crops; whereas, in the Gamo, they have more than 65 varieties of barley, more than 12 varieties of wheat and more than 100 varieties of enset and dozens of varieties of cassava, taro and yam. The Gamo defies the common assumption that agricultural intensification decreases biodiversity.
Furthermore, in UNEP’s analysis of 114 organic projects across 24 countries, researchers found that not only did financial stability and quality of life improve, but yields increased by up to 116%, out-performing conventional industrial agriculture.
The Gamo people and culture are embedded in an ecosystem that is intensively managed and yet, unlike ours, includes an astounding amount of diversity, stability and resilience. Over thousands of years they have evolved a way of being in the world that has ensured their long-term survival. Their management of everything; from water tables, soil nutrient cycles to their social infrastructure stems from a view of the world as sacred, alive and entirely interconnected.
We’ll leave the final words to Gamoan elder Kapo Kansa:
“It is not permitted among Gamoans to take out whatever one likes from the ground. There is a limit. You are taking grasses which you need. You don’t destroy others. You are taking trees for your consumption. Not to destroy others. You want to pass a resource on for the coming generation.”